SCP-3460 / Discussion

This is the discussion related to the wiki page SCP-3460.

page 1 of 212next »

Time for something that is not Anderson.

Jacob Conwell 30 Oct 2017 00:09

So this is an idea I got a few nights ago, and decided to take a crack at. Probably not the most ground breaking article in the world, but hey, I think its cool, and it opens the door for a lot of potential tales/expansion. Also my first time writing a Thaumiel

Thanks to A Random Day, DrBleep, Modern_Erasmus, BananaRepublic, MaliceAforethought, Taffeta, 9Volt, Zyn, Sly161, Weryllium, Lazar Lyusternik, LordStonefish, GreenWolf, and djkaktus for critique.

Enjoy the article.

Conwell

NatVoltaic 30 Oct 2017 00:15

This a short but sweet read, with a clever exploitation of an otherwise simple anomaly to make it very cool. The information on it's discovery was also pretty interesting and has some nice implications.

+1

Modern_Erasmus 30 Oct 2017 00:19

Good to see this up! I love the potential ways this could be used.

Taffeta 30 Oct 2017 00:48

You've gotta keep em separated.

Jacob Conwell 30 Oct 2017 01:46

Hey - man you talkin' back to me?

Abettik 30 Oct 2017 02:03

-1

Found this quite boring, and uninteresting.

+ Show

I also found the description clunky and confusing, and didn't really understand it until the first log. I actually STILL don't understand what the needles measure on their own, if you just leave them and watch. Then, the logs were generally repetitive, until the last one, where it almost seemed like a narrative "solution in search of a problem," so to speak. I guess what I'm trying to say there is that while I could see the potential in how it -could- be used, the document didn't organically get me to care. Maybe if you had delved deeper into the person trying to keep their stalker/ex away… or gone into why it was created (maybe a guy trying to create a run-in with some girl), or made it a bit more interesting on its own, I could upvote in good faith.

Jacob Conwell 30 Oct 2017 02:08

Thank you for your feedback.

I know it's written "living" individual but...

DrGersch 30 Oct 2017 13:54

What happens when you align the needle and kill one of the individuals ?

Re: I know it's written "living" individual but...

Jacob Conwell 30 Oct 2017 15:35

Since the needles don't work on the deceased, they would snap back to neutral position.

Queen Grayhoof 30 Oct 2017 18:49

Very interesting article! It's simple and short, but its uses are numerous. +1

Buttfranklin 30 Oct 2017 21:35

This feels way too dangerous for the Foundation to test so extensively. It caused a Site to catch fire in order to fulfil its command, so the risk of malevolent genie action seems too high – especially when you consider that there's no apparent limit to this object's powers.

I'd also echo the gist of Abettik's comment, although perhaps not its coarseness.

Jacob Conwell 30 Oct 2017 22:39

Thank you for your feedback.

Update

Jacob Conwell 31 Oct 2017 04:47

Logs have been altered, containment procedures tweaked, incident log added, and minor details changed here and there.

mlister 28 Nov 2018 21:49

The testing log was more of a compelling and engaging read that it has any right to be. With that said, the CI plotline seemed poorly foreshadowed, and even though it's obviously the "twist" of the SCP, I still don't quite get the ramifications of the incident, and I feel like the article can be restructured to make it more obvious.

---

No signature defined.

Jacob Conwell 29 Nov 2018 02:27

Glad the test log was entertaining.

With respect to your comments RE: The CI plotline and its ramifications.

Basically, the SCP Foundation used this thing like mad shortly after its discovery since it was a very useful device for tracking down PoIs and seemed like it was low risk. However, by having several MTF agents bonded to several CI agents via SCP-3460, they may have inadvertently caused a massive CI raid on their own facility via the devices probabilities altering abilities. This caused them to reel in their use of the device, requiring O5 approval, and large amounts of down time between uses. In short, SCP has a super useful device, overuse it, and have it bite them in the ass in a bad way.

My plan was to foreshadow this with the initial update to the containment procedures, and then hint that things were heading towards catastrophe with the final entry of the test log, though I can see why that might be a little weak sauce.

page 1 of 212next »