Hey guys! Thanks to Zyn for feedback in the IAB stage and thanks to Chubert for some good feedback on the drafts forums! The image was taken by me.
Gotta say, I always love an SCP that has to be interviewed in weird, roundabout ways. +1
I dig the communication system, as well as the events leading up to its classification. +1 from me!
Yeah. You had my +1 with the basic concept, but the interview was definitely next level. Well done!
The d20+d6 seems needlessly complicated. Why not make a d30+ with letters instead of numbers? Or a dozen such dice?
Aside from that I like it. There are a few places that could be improved, mostly with wording and tone.
Eh, for the initial interview I feel like what I have now is sufficient. Maybe if they kept doing more interviews they would move to a simpler form, one with dice with letters on them. They only problem is that they would have to probably create the dice for that themselves.
Also, do you have any examples of where tone and wording can be improved? I've read this too much and may be skimming over them.
Hey hey HEY. That is not a "standard miniature".
That is an ultramarines, 41st millenium, fourth edition, third company veteran with standard armament!
The emperor protects >:C
(Also, upvote :D)
Hey, we gotta keep it simple for the masses!
The picture is actually of the first figure I built and painted, I'm working on a Necron army currently (I like the aesthetics a lot for crons, they prob my favorite race in all aspects).
Kick ass! I don't actually play the tabletop, but I'm a huge fan of the universe, novels, video games, and rpgs.
I would suggest, putting in a footnote of the various identifying characteristics. Ultrasmurfs aren't exactly rare lol.
The moment I saw it was a 40k figure, I knew a bunch of people on the site who would probably like it…
That being said, as someone with no 40K experience, I thought this was an excellent example of an uncomplicated anomaly written to depth. I love that the note from the doctor, although clinical, expresses guilt at leaving a sapient object locked in a featureless box for months. I like the object's explanation for why it got in trouble and its affection for its owner, the interview log works well, and it's clean enough to avoid getting tangled up in any details. A short and sweet +1.
Pretty neat. I don't feel like the final addendum is necessary, as it's basically regurgitating plot points from the interview in a less-entertaining fashion. Also, this bit here:
After several tests to confirm that it wasn't just luck
Is a little tone-breaking - it may just be the contraction, though.
I feel like you could cut the strike-through paragraph, doesn't seem like it adds anything of value.
Finally, formatting/pacing could use a bit of work: I think this would read better if you opened with the Anomalous Item entry, as this:
The object's only apparent anomalous property is an influence over the outcome of dice rolls within a 50 cm radius caused by unknown means.
Should have included the fact that it is sapient by the time it was classified as an SCP. Another interview might have been nice as well, I think, but everything else listed is barring me from an upvote - more time with the character would just have been icing on the cake.
Thanks, I'm currently in class and on mobile so I'll see what I can do when I get home. I may remove the final addendum if others agree that it's unnecessary.
As for tone and formatting, I'll give it another run down and see what I can change.
I made a small phrasing edit for the luck thing. Do you think it fits better?
Games Workshop has been known to try to go after works that merely have "space marine" in the title (and wasn't a derivative work at all) with Cease and Desists and obviously this article is much more WH40K derived. I think everything here is fair use, but on the other hand it is clear that GW has a different definition of fair use.
Also an upvote for the Empire of Man!
Should we wait and see if anything happens? I think we should be fine but I'm not an expert.
Yeah, no reason to worry about it yet, I just wanted to note they have a history of this in case they do get aggro, it won't be a shock.






