hiiii thank you for reading my Secret Creepy Pasta C: i hope you enjoyed this piece about how much i fucking hate cigarettes!! xoxo
hello again! based on some of the feedback i've received, i've removed one of the extraneous test logs. thank you all for your apt feedback!
Executes the concept well with a great ending. Nice work!
thank you! really appreciate the feedback :)
This needed an editing pass pretty bad. There are several SCP-0000s present, a few sentences with poor construction, and a few general SPaG errors.
The concept itself is fine enough, just played a bit too straight for my tastes. I would be able to novote at that alone, but the biggest issue I see here is pacing. You have a tendency to repeat information to the reader over and over (you state several times the one agent was religious), and you randomly start doing D-Class tests on the object that don't really do much as far as moving a story forward or giving us new, interesting information.
The most interesting part of this narratively was the fact that the agent still had cravings after getting a memory wipe, which imo would've been a great thread to follow. It would've really carried the theme of addiction to a more satisfying conclusion than what you currently have, which just plays up the anomalous body horror too much. -1
hi ori! thanks for catching those placeholders - i've got dyscalculia, so numbers are a bit hard for me. *note: they should be fixed, but if missed any pls flag it up!
i also appreciate the honest feedback! my goal was to steer the ship more toward the body horror; to me, that's one of the scariest parts of smoking (and why i quit a while back)…seeing actual cancer cells kinda fucks with you while you're mid cig, yknow?. i'll cut down on the fluff and up the nuance next time :)
Congrats on your first SCP! I think this is pretty decent; there are good moments like the blobbed family, I like the dialogue and the character personalities, and this is generally written with a pretty good clinical tone. To me, you've got an SCP that takes a concept (smoking causes cancer) to a pretty horrific extreme. It's a simple enough idea, but the article does explore it in multiple ways, which was nice. And, y'know, hating smoking is an admirable cause.
I do agree with Ori that this could've used more polish. Not just the few typos or other strangely written sentences; it's also a long article which repeats information a lot, which made it a bit tedious to read. For example, the test logs mostly just told us stuff we already knew about the anomaly, which bogged down the few good details, and the 911 call transcript is quite generic. The ending report also doesn't do much for me, and it feels like there were other stronger ideas you could've explored than a smoker going rogue. For a first article, this is great, but there's definitely a lot of room for improvement. Novoting.
Pretty much everything I want to say here hs been said. This article lacks a core pathos and has no hook, and because everything is played so straight, it’s impossible to glean anything substantial. -1
nya? (runs headfirst into a wall and explodes)
find my work here: https://scp-wiki.wikidot.com/xexnoncores-author
I love the poorly censored 7/11. Gave me a good chuckle
wait until you find out the family of 4 is actually the bueller family from ferris bueller's day off






