This is the log from the room. I've edited out some of the extraneous stuff.
<Scrungles> ok, elevator pitch. so my SCP is an old gramophone that, depending on the song and the life experiences of the listener, will create personalized hallucinations
<aonly9470> hmm…. what sort of hallucinations?
<Scrungles> say its a love song and somebody currently has a crush, their hallucinations will be centered around falling in love with that person
<Scrungles> well, they would be extremely vivid, almost dream like, as if you were in a different world
<•MalyceGraves> Ok, where was this gramophone found?
<Scrungles> 3 burglars stole it from a house in the 1940's, however, they played some rather sad songs and started feeling depressed and anxious around it, so they turned it into the police, and the foundation then took it off the police
<Scrungles> As in, the burglars turned it in along with themselves
<•MalyceGraves> Ok. Why was the thing made in the first place?
<Scrungles> oh wow, thats a good question that I didn't think of. i suppose my idea was that it was a "malfunctioning" gramophone (it dated back to 1889) but it simply just an anomaly
<•MalyceGraves> So, you have the start of a decent narrative
<Scrungles> thats good to hear
<•MalyceGraves> The thing is that just a thing what does a thing isn't something that flies well these days.
<Scrungles> ahh, i was afraid i had written one of those
<•MalyceGraves> So you gotta give it some sort of narrative punch. It has to tell a story past just "hey, here is this cool thing"
<Scrungles> yeah, ill have to expand
<•MalyceGraves> I think you're somewhere in the middle. It's an interesting anomaly, you just need more with it. You could go forward or backwards in time. Discover a compartment with some yellowing sheets of paper in cracked and aging envelopes. Letters from the Maker to whoever they gave it to. Love letters? apologies? "Hey, I'm so proud of you, live your dreams" letters from an old grandpa to his starry-eyed grandson?
<Scrungles> my idea was to include a lot of test logs featuring a D-Class listening to different music, this D-Class had lived a particularly interesting life, and due to his hallucinations he would of changed as a person
<•MalyceGraves> Everyone goes down the test log route
<Scrungles> oooh, i like the compartment idea
<•MalyceGraves> It can be done well, I'm not saying that, it's just a well-trod path to relaying your story
<Scrungles> no, thats fair enough, i want to write a good story, not just one that "exists"
As I said, I think the idea has a good starting place. Develop more of the narrative and explore it a bit more, and you'll have a fine piece.